Smaller, Younger, and More Impactful: How AI-Assisted Writing Transforms Research Teams
更小、更年轻、更具影响力:AI辅助写作如何改变研究团队
Haoyang Wang, Mingze Zhang, Yi Bu, Star Xing Zhao, Meijun Liu
AI总结 本研究利用2020年以来的PLoS和Nature系列期刊全文,通过多种回归方法发现AI辅助写作使研究团队更年轻、规模更小,且不影响甚至提升科学影响力。
详情
大科学时代长期以来以日益庞大和专门化的研究团队推动知识前沿为特征。然而,人工智能(AI)的最新进展,特别是大型语言模型(LLMs),正开始重塑学术写作和科学研究,可能打破长期以来团队规模不断扩大的趋势,并改变研究团队结构的其他维度。基于2020年以来PLoS系列和Nature系列期刊的147,074篇全文出版物,我们考察了AI辅助写作是否以及如何影响科学中的团队结构和团队成果。使用多种方法,包括普通最小二乘法、分位数回归、泊松回归、逻辑回归和倾向得分匹配,我们发现使用AI辅助写作的研究团队往往更年轻、规模更小。重要的是,这种向更紧凑、更年轻化团队的转变并非以牺牲科学影响力为代价。相反,我们观察到采用AI辅助写作的研究团队产生高影响力出版物的概率更高。这些结果凸显了AI辅助写作在重塑研究生产方式以及研究团队组建和构成方面的重要作用。我们的发现呼吁在研究评估、资助和培训方面进行政策改进,以应对这一新兴趋势。
The era of Big Science has long been defined by increasingly large and specialized research teams pushing the frontiers of knowledge. However, recent advances in artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs), are beginning to reshape academic writing and scientific research, potentially disrupting the longstanding trend toward ever-larger teams and transforming other dimensions of research team structure. Drawing on 147,074 full-text publications from the PLoS family and the Nature portfolio since 2020, we examined whether and how AI-assisted writing influences team structure and team outcomes in science. Using multiple methods, including ordinary least square, quantile regression, Poisson regression, logistic regression and propensity score matching, we found that research teams using AI-assisted writing tend to be younger and smaller. Importantly, this shift toward more compact, junior-leaning teams does not come at the expense of scientific impact. On the contrary, we observed a higher probability of research teams that employed AI-assisted writing producing highly impactful publications. These results highlight the significant role of AI-assisted writing in reshaping not only how research is produced, but also how research teams are formed and assembled. Our findings call for policy improvements in research evaluation, funding, and training to address this emerging trend.