Fine-Grained Benchmark Generation for Comprehensive Evaluation of Foundation Models
细粒度基准生成用于基础模型的全面评估
Mohammed Saidul Islam, Negin Baghbanzadeh, Farnaz Kohankhaki, Afshin Cheraghi, Ali Kore, Shayaan Mehdi, Elham Dolatabadi, Arash Afkanpour
AI总结 本文提出了一种自动化基准生成框架,用于生成覆盖广泛、元数据丰富且抗污染的评估问题,从而提升基础模型的全面评估能力。
详情
基础模型的评估通常依赖于缺乏全面覆盖和细粒度评估元数据的基准汇总分数。我们引入了一个自动化基准生成框架。该框架生成基于参考材料(如教科书)的评估问题,生成具有广泛覆盖、丰富元数据和抗污染性的基准。该流程采用多代理架构进行问题生成,并采用以解决方案图驱动的策略,显著提高了地面真实解决方案的可靠性。使用该框架,我们生成了三个基准:机器学习、公司金融和个人金融。专家审查发现,其地面真实错误率显著低于之前的基准,如MMLU和GSM8K。对12个商业和开源模型的评估显示,我们的基准实现了接近均匀的竞争力覆盖,并揭示了现有基准未能捕捉到的模型间性能差异。我们即将开源该框架和我们精心挑选的基准。
Evaluation of foundation models often rely on aggregate scores from benchmarks that lack comprehensive coverage and metadata for a fine-grained evaluation. We introduce a framework for automated benchmark generation. Our framework generates evaluation problems grounded in reference material, such as textbooks, producing benchmarks with broad coverage, rich metadata, and robustness to contamination. The pipeline employs a multi-agent architecture for problem generation and a solution-graph-driven strategy that significantly improves the reliability of ground truth solutions. Using the framework, we generate three benchmarks in Machine Learning, Corporate Finance, and Personal Finance. Expert review finds a significantly lower ground-truth error rate than previous benchmarks such as MMLU and GSM8K. Evaluation of 12 commercial and open-source models shows that our benchmarks achieve near-uniform competency coverage and surface performance differences across models that existing benchmarks fail to capture. We will open-source the framework and our curated benchmarks soon.