The Complex Brain Hypothesis: Resolving the Entropy-Content Conundrum in Minimal Phenomenal Experience
复杂大脑假说:解决最小现象体验中的熵-内容困境
Jonas Mago, Edmundo Lopez-Sola, Jakub Vohryzek, Michael Lifshitz, Robin Carhart-Harris, Karl Friston, Shamil Chandaria
AI总结 本文提出复杂大脑假说,认为现象丰富性应由大脑复杂性而非熵来衡量,通过分析不同意识状态的神经机制,澄清了最小现象体验与高内容体验之间的差异。
详情
最小现象体验(MPEs)是意识状态,其中清醒保持但现象内容低或缺失。熵脑假说(EBH)将自发脑活动的熵视为'现象丰富性'的标志,例如高内容迷幻体验(HCPEs)。然而,最近的人脑成像研究显示,由冥想或5-MeO-DMT诱导的MPEs表现出增加的神经生理熵。这给EBH带来困境:脑熵在现象丰富性增加或减少时都升高。本文提出复杂大脑假说(CBH),认为现象丰富性应由复杂性而非熵来衡量。我们论证大脑复杂性受推理粒度调节:某些HCPEs体现细粒度模式,放松约束放大波动产生丰富内容;某些MPEs体现粗粒度模式,简单模型溶解多样性产生'无内容'意识。两种模式均可与高脑熵相关,但现象学和扰动特征不同。通过解决熵-内容困境,CBH改进EBH并强调MPEs作为意识计算理论的重要测试案例。
Minimal Phenomenal Experiences (MPEs) are states of consciousness in which wakefulness is preserved but phenomenal content is low or absent. The Entropic Brain Hypothesis (EBH) is a model of conscious processes that regards the entropy of spontaneous brain activity as a marker of 'phenomenal richness', exemplified by high-content psychedelic experiences (HCPEs). Yet recent human neuroimaging studies of MPEs induced by meditation -- and possibly 5-MeO-DMT -- suggest that these states, defined by their phenomenological simplicity, also show signs of increased neurophysiological entropy. This presents a conundrum for the EBH: brain entropy is elevated with increased and decreased richness of the phenomenal experience. Here, we put forward the Complex Brain Hypothesis (CBH), which proposes that the richness of experience differentiating MPEs from HCPEs is better indexed by complexity than by entropy. We argue that brain complexity is modulated by the grain of inference through which the brain resolves uncertainty: some HCPEs exemplify a fine-grained regime, in which loosened constraints amplify fluctuations into proliferating content, whereas some MPEs exemplify a coarse-grained regime, in which a simpler model dissolves variety into an experience of 'contentless' awareness. Both regimes can be associated with elevated brain entropy, but they diverge in phenomenology and perturbational signatures. By resolving the entropy-content conundrum, the CBH refines the EBH and highlights MPEs as an important test case for computational theories of consciousness.