Constitutional Governance in Metric Spaces
Ehud Shapiro, Nimrod Talmon
AI总结 本文研究了在度量空间中实现平等自主治理的计算机制,提出了宪法治理框架,将提案、审议、修改和共识等过程整合为一个多项式时间协议。该框架通过为每个可修改的组件分配度量空间、聚合规则和超级多数阈值,支持成员通过理想元素投票并提交获得超级多数支持的公开提案,从而实现宪法共识。研究还展示了该框架在七个典型场景中的应用,并证明了广义中位数在多数阈值下具有良好的激励相容性,为数字社区和组织的宪法治理提供了全面解决方案。
详情
Computational social choice and algorithmic decision theory offer rich aggregation theory but no comprehensive process for egalitarian self-governance: aggregation, deliberation, amendment, and consensus are each considered in isolation, with key metric-space aggregators being NP-hard. Here, we propose constitutional governance in metric spaces, integrating these stages into a coherent polynomial-time protocol for constitutional governance. The constitution assigns, per amendable component including itself, a metric space, aggregation rule, and supermajority threshold. Amendments proceed by members voting with their ideal elements, followed by members submitting public proposals carrying supermajority public support under the revealed votes. Public proposals can be sourced from deliberation among members, vote aggregation, or AI mediation. The constitutional rule adopts a supported proposal with positive maximal score, if there is one, else retains the status quo. With Constitutional Consensus, a community can run the constitutional governance protocol on members' personal computing devices (e.g., smartphones), achieving digital sovereignty. We focus on the utility of the generalised median, prove that at majority threshold no misreport weakly dominates sincere voting, and study the compromise gap between best peak and unconstrained optimum. We instantiate the framework to seven canonical settings -- electing officers, setting rates, allocating budgets, ranking priorities, selecting boards, drafting bylaws, and amending the constitution. By unifying metric-space aggregation, reality-aware social choice, supermajority amendment, constitutional consensus, deliberative coalition formation, and AI mediation, this work delivers a comprehensive solution to the constitutional governance of digital communities and organisations.