AgentCollabBench: Diagnosing When Good Agents Make Bad Collaborators
Aritra Mazumder, Shubhashis Roy Dipta, Nusrat Jahan Lia, Tanzila Khan, Kainat Raisa Hossain, Nehaa Shri, Shubhrangshu Debsarkar, Humayra Tasnim, Gour Gupal Talukder Shawon, Debjoty Mitra, Sumaiya Ahmed Rani, Al Jami Islam Anik, Al Nafeu Khan
AI总结 AgentCollabBench 是一个用于诊断优秀智能体为何可能成为不良协作伙伴的基准测试平台,旨在揭示多智能体系统中潜在的推理链失效问题。该研究通过构建包含900个人工验证任务的基准,评估了四种现代大语言模型在指令衰减、虚假信念传播、上下文泄露和追踪数据持久性等方面的脆弱性,并发现通信拓扑结构是影响多跳信息传递可靠性的关键因素。研究指出,多智能体系统的可靠性本质上是结构问题,仅提升模型能力不足以保障协作安全。
详情
Multi-agent systems achieve state-of-the-art outcomes through peer collaboration. However, when an agent in the pipeline silently drops a constraint, the system's final output may look correct even though the reasoning chain was quietly corrupted, and existing outcome-based evaluations are blind to such multi-hop process failures. To make these vulnerabilities measurable before deployment, we introduce AgentCollabBench, a diagnostic benchmark of 900 human-validated tasks spanning software engineering, DevOps, and data engineering. Each task isolates one of four behavioral risks: instruction decay (does a constraint survive peer pressure?), false-belief contagion (does a falsehood spread through consensus?), context leakage (does information bleed between tasks?), and tracer durability (does marked data reach the final agent?). Evaluating four modern LLMs (GPT 4.1 mini, Gemini 2.5 Flash Lite, Qwen-3.5-35B-A3B, and Llama 3.1 8B Instruct), we expose model-specific vulnerability profiles invisible to outcome-only evaluation; Qwen-3.5-35B-A3B, for example, leads on tracer durability and instruction stability, while GPT 4.1 mini leads on leakage containment and false-belief resistance. Beyond per-model differences, communication topology emerges as a primary risk factor that explains 7-40% of the variance in multi-hop information survival. The effect traces to a synthesis bottleneck specific to converging-DAG nodes: an agent weighing competing parent inputs discards constraints carried by a minority branch, a bottleneck structurally absent from linear chains. AgentCollabBench demonstrates that suboptimal topology can silently erase the safeguards of highly capable models, arguing that multi-agent reliability is fundamentally a structural problem and that scaling model intelligence alone is no substitute for architecture.